Page 1 of 5
European Journal of Business &
Social Sciences
Available at https://ejbss.org/
ISSN: 2235-767X
Volume 07 Issue 05
May 2019
Available online:https://ejbss.org/ P a g e | 992
Study On The Effect Of Geometric Design Consistency On Level Of Safety On Intercity
Roads
A. KUMANAN
DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING
PRIST (Deemed to be University)THANJAVUR.
ABSTRACT
This paper focuses on analysing the influence of geometric design characteristics on traffic
safety using bi-directional data on a divided roadway operated under heterogeneous traffic
conditions in India. The study was carried out on a four lanedivided inter-city highway in
plain and rolling terrain. Statistical modelling approachby Poisson regression and Negative
binomial regression were used to assess the safetyperformance as occurrence of crashes are
random events and to identify the influenceof the geometric design variables on the crash
frequency. Negative binomialregression model was found to be more suitable to identify the
variables contributingto road crashes. The study enabled better understanding of the factors
related to roadgeometrics that influence road crash frequency. The study also established that
operating speed has a significant contribution to the total number of crashes. Negative
binomial models are found to be appropriate to predict road crashes on divided roadways
under heterogeneous traffic conditions.
INTRODUCTION
Traffic safety is of major concern in a
developing country. Researches on traffic
safetyhave been widely reported
since1960s, Solomon (1964) relating road
crashes in ruralhighways to speed, vehicle
and driver. Several studies have been
carried out toidentify the factors
contributing to road crashes and measures
to reduce the crash rate.
Several reported studies relate geometric
design consistency to road crashes are
underhomogeneous traffic conditions
(Aljanahi et al., 1999; Aram, 2010; Cafiso
et al.,2010; Hadayeghi et al., 2003; Kang
et al., 2005; Lee et al., 2011; Naderan and
Babaei,2011; Persaud, 1994, 2000). Road
crashes are complex events and are
influenced bymany factors such as road
geometric design, traffic volume and
composition, speeddifferentials between
Page 2 of 5
European Journal of Business &
Social Sciences
Available at https://ejbss.org/
ISSN: 2235-767X
Volume 07 Issue 05
May 2019
Available online:https://ejbss.org/ P a g e | 993
vehicles of the same class and different
classes, weather,motivation for travelling,
driver's physical and mental conditions
and so on (Aljanahiet al., 1999). In India,
as per the recent statistics, around 0.14
million people die and0.4 million people
get injured due to road crashes every year,
with a fatality rate of11.8 (MORTH,
2015). Approximately half of road crash
victims are vulnerable roaduser's viz.
motorcyclists, pedestrians and cyclists
(WHO, 2009). The traffic conditionsare
highly heterogeneous in India, where the
traffic comprises vehicles with
diversestatic and dynamic characteristics
and all such vehicles use the same right-of- waywithout any physical segregation.
Thus, the vehicles of the said
heterogeneous traffic,under highvolume
conditions, move on Indian roads by
sharing the available roadspace without
sufficient lateral as well as longitudinal
clearances. The lane-lessmovement further
add to the complexity of
analysing/modelling heterogeneous traffic.
Under heterogeneous traffic, the effect of
speed reduction on vehicles of the same
class and vehicles of different classes and
their speed differentials along curves on
road safety needs an investigation.
Research works were conducted to
evaluate the influence of speed on the
safety ofroadways. According to
AASHTO - geometric design of highways
and streets (2001), “the safest speed for
any highway depends on design features,
road conditions, trafficvolumes, weather
conditions, roadside development, spacing
of intersecting roads,cross-traffic volumes,
and other factors”. Most of the studies
considered the operatingspeed as the 85th
percentile speed of those vehicles
travelling on the roadway andfound speed- related crashes are more likely to occur at
mid-blocks than atintersections (Lamm et
al., 1990; Liu and Chen, 2009; Lu, 2006).
Models were alsodeveloped to study the
dependence of crash rates on speed and
geometriccharacteristics, which showed
that they are not linearly related (Garber
and Ehrhart,2000). Vehicle speed could be
related to trafficsafety in two ways: (a)
greater avehicle's velocity, lesser the time
available for the driver to react to a hazard
in thepresence of other motorists,
bicyclists, or pedestrians. If this
relationship exists, itwould be expressed in
relative incidence of crashes at different
speeds and (b) due tothe physical
relationship of mass and speed to energy,
it would be possible to expressthe relative
Page 3 of 5
European Journal of Business &
Social Sciences
Available at https://ejbss.org/
ISSN: 2235-767X
Volume 07 Issue 05
May 2019
Available online:https://ejbss.org/ P a g e | 994
severity of crashes at different speeds
(FHWA, 1998). Most of the studies
were carried out on undivided rural
highways and a few on divided highways.
Research related to geometric
characteristics showed that few variables
havesignificant effect on the safety of
roadways. Radius of curves was identified
as one ofthe significant variables while
defining the effect of horizontal and
vertical curves onroad crashes and also
while estimating the speeds on rural
highways. Crash rate wasfound to increase
significantly when radii are below 200 m
(Aram, 2010; FHWA,2000). Super
elevation, degree of curve, shoulder width
and average daily traffic alsocontributes to
road crashes (Aram, 2010). Researchers
also concluded that roads withheavier
traffic volume, more road lanes and higher
speed limits tend to have moresevere
crashes (Ma et al., 2010).
DATA DESCRIPTION
The study is carried out on a four lane
divided intercity highway of 100 km
aligned inplain and rolling terrain in India
catering to heterogeneous traffic condition.
The data related to geometric design
characteristics were collected using
Hawkeye; automated data collection
equipmentdeveloped by ARRB and was
extracted using Hawkeye processing
toolkit by standardrating form.Crash
history was collected from records for the
study stretch for a period of fouryears,
from 2009 to 2012. The data includes the
type and cause of the crashes, time ofday,
details of the vehicles and victims,
weather, roadway geometrics etc. The
study stretch and it can be seen that over
speed contributes to 39% of the total
crashes. The crash frequencies are
observed tobe different for both directions
of travel as seen in Fig. 3. The crash rate
ofsouthbound traffic was approximately
60%, whereas it is 40% in the case of
northbound. This data provides motivation
for the present study.
Geometric characteristics of the highway
such as gradient, cross slope, horizontal
curvature, vertical curvature, pavement
width, shoulder condition and shoulder
widthwere collected using Hawkeye as
mentioned earlier and are shown in Fig. 4
(a) and
(b). It can be seen from these figures that
the geometric design characteristics are not
uniform throughout the roadway. The
variations in geometric characteristics may
