Page 1 of 5
European Journal of Business &
Social Sciences
Available at https://ejbss.org/
ISSN: 2235-767X
Volume 07 Issue 05
May 2019
Available online:https://ejbss.org/ P a g e | 876
Traffic Flow Modeling Under Heterogeneous Traffic Conditions
M. VENKATESAN
DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING
PRIST (Deemed to be University), THANJAVUR.
Abstract
A comprehensive methodology for modelling the heterogeneous traffic is presented in this
article. Considering the no-lane discipline and the presence of various sizes of vehicles,
several microscopic and macroscopic traffic variables are analysed for their suitability in
describing the heterogeneous traffic. Applicability in the modelling process and the feasibility
in collecting field data are the important criteria used in deciding the suitable traffic variables.
In place of occupancy, its variant termed as area occupancy was found to be suitable in
describing the heterogeneous traffic.
INTRODUCTION
Traffic composed of identical vehicles and
following the lane discipline is termed as
homogeneous. Traffic comprising of
motorised and non-motorised two- wheelers (TWs) and three-wheelers along
with several other vehicles with no-lane
discipline is termed as heterogeneous. This
heterogeneous traffic is clearly different
from the one with the presence of trucks
which has also been termed as
heterogeneous traffic. The absence of lane
discipline results in vehicular movement
that is influenced by the presence of
vehicles in the front as well as on the
sides. This led to a complex traffic
behaviour and it cannot be analysed by
using conventional microscopic and
macroscopic traffic variables. Using
conventional measurement techniques, it is
also difficult to collect the data. Modelling
methodology to be adopted in these
conditions would also be considerably
different compared to the existing traffic
modelling methodologies. Traffic flow
variables, relationships among the
variables and the observed data on these
variables are the crucialinputs for the
traffic flow modelling purposes. Any
efforts in the area of traffic flow modelling
should consider the above aspects and it is
even more crucial when dealing with the
heterogeneous traffic. In this scenario,
formulating new theoretical and modelling
concepts or adopting the conventional
Page 2 of 5
European Journal of Business &
Social Sciences
Available at https://ejbss.org/
ISSN: 2235-767X
Volume 07 Issue 05
May 2019
Available online:https://ejbss.org/ P a g e | 877
microscopic and macroscopic traffic flow
concepts are the available alternatives for
the researchers.
Several researchers (Chari and Badarinath
1983, Palaniswamy et al. 1985,
Ramanayya 1988, Kumar 1994, Singh
1999, Oketch 2000) have attempted to
model the heterogeneous traffic and most
of these models are microscopic in nature.
Some researchers (Chari and Badarinath
1983, Singh 1999) have proposed
alternative measures for density, but where
exactly they fit into the overall modelling
process and the relationship with the other
traffic variables were not clearly
discussed. Explicit vehicular interactions
under varying traffic conditions are
modelled in these studies. Vehicle
composition and the gap maintaining
behaviour were the important input data to
these models. In most of these studies,
video recording techniques were utilised in
collecting the data on vehicular
interactions. Video recording technique
requires extensive manpower to collect the
data on vehicular interactions and is prone
to error. Some other data collection
techniques, such as dualloop detectors,
image processing-based traffic data
collection techniques, can be used to
estimate vehicle lengths which in turn can
be used in estimating vehicle width (Lan
and Kuo 2002). Using these techniques,
vehicle lengths under free-flow conditions
can be found with a fair amount of
accuracy. To overcome the errors observed
in forced-flow conditions in measuring
vehicle lengths, Zhang et al. (2005)
proposed a new dual-loop algorithm which
can handle erroneous raw loop actuation
signals. Lateral gap data that are equally
important to model the vehicular
interactions can be collected using a
recently developed image processing
software called TRAZER (Mallikarjuna et
al. 2009). Implementing the cellular
automata (CA) concept for modelling the
heterogeneous traffic has been suggested
by some researchers (Lan and Chang 2005,
Hsu et al. 2007, Mallikarjuna and
Ramachandra Rao 2009). Lan and Hsu
(2006) have proposed new variants for
density and flow using the modified CA
structure developed for modelling the
heterogeneous traffic. These variants have
been derived based on generalised
definitions for speed, flow and the density
(Edie 1965, Maerivoet 2006). Mallikarjuna
and Ramachandra Rao (2006) have
proposed a new variant for occupancy
termed as area occupancy and this variable
was found to be suitable for CA-based
modelling methodology. Mallikarjuna and
Page 3 of 5
European Journal of Business &
Social Sciences
Available at https://ejbss.org/
ISSN: 2235-767X
Volume 07 Issue 05
May 2019
Available online:https://ejbss.org/ P a g e | 878
Ramachandra Rao (2009) have proposed a
detailed methodology in formulating the
CA structure for modelling the
heterogeneous traffic. Field traffic data
collected using the video image
processing-based software, TRAZER
(Mallikarjuna et al. 2009), has been
utilised in formulating this CA structure.
In this article, an effort is made to develop
a comprehensive methodology to model
the heterogeneous traffic. While choosing
the appropriate traffic variables, factors
such as the usefulness in describing the
traffic, data measurability and usefulness
in modelling are taken into consideration.
Important microscopic variables, such as
lateral gaps, longitudinal gaps and lateral
distribution of vehicles have been utilised
in formulating the CA structure. Data
collected on these variables using video
image processing software, TRAZER,
have been analysed. Relationship between
area occupancy and a variant of flow
measured in terms of cells has been
utilised in calibrating and validating the
proposed CA model. Model validation was
done using the field data collected on
different road sections. Data collected
from the simulation model in terms of
cells, which are the basic units of vehicles
in the modified CA structure, are found to
be conforming to the fundamental traffic
flow theory. The organisation of the
remainder of this article is presented
below.
CALIBRATION AND VALIDATION
OF THE CA MODEL
In this study the macroscopic traffic
variables, such as flow, speed and density
are defined differently to incorporate the
heterogeneous nature of the traffic (Lan
and Hsu 2006, Mallikarjuna and
Ramachandra Rao 2006). The basis for
these modifications follows conventional
traffic measurements over a general
measurement region (Figure 1). Since lane
discipline is absent under heterogeneous
traffic conditions, measurements taken
over a single lane have no relevance under
these conditions. To overcome these
problems, each cell (which is a part of the
vehicle) is considered as one vehicle and
each sub-lane is considered as one lane
while taking measurements over the
general measurement region (Figure 4).
On account of the above assumptions, the
cells (unit vehicle size) inevitably follow
the lane discipline. A measurement region
of width W, length L and at time T is
considered while taking the measurements.
The traffic variables, such as flow, speed
