Page 1 of 17
European Journal of Business &
Social Sciences
Available at https://ejbss.org/
ISSN: 2235-767X
Volume 07 Issue 05
May 2019
Available online: https://ejbss.org/ P a g e | 238
Corporate Social Responsibility and Competitive Advantage of Private
Telecom Sector in Afghanistan
Masood Khan,
Ph.D. (Research Scholar),
Department of Management Studies,
Vivekananda Global University,
India
Dr. Pankaj Meel,
Ph.D. (Research Guide),
Associate Professor,
Department of Management Studies,
Vivekananda Global University,
India
Abstract
The study determined Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) practices and the link between CSR and
Competitive Advantages of private telecom sector in Afghanistan. Specifically, the research examined
current ongoing practices of CSR performed by private telecommunication companies in Afghanistan,
the competitive role engaging in CSR among the companies and all those challenges which influence to
affect company by implementing CSR. A survey questionnaire of 100 people including employees,
customers and community to selected GSM companies i.e. AWCC, Roshan, MTN, and Etisalat were
distributed to collect primary data for achieving its purpose by qualitative methodology. All level of
employees and customers were sampled for the study. Both statistical tools, descriptive and inferential,
were used. The research came into being and found that Afghan private telecom companies are mainly
engaged in CSR practices are Community Relations, Environmental Relations and many other CSR
activities as Employee Relations for providing positive image of the companies, branding and used it as
marketing tool to gain competitive advantage or higher profit. The study found that by engaging in CSR,
ROSHAN gained higher competitive range among all other private telecom companies in Afghanistan.
Key words:
CSR, private telecom sector, competitive advantage, AWCC, Roshan, MTN, Etisalat
Introduction
CSR is an arising topic of the twentieth Century during past late years. It refers to the commitment of
firms towards stakeholders and society, According to Carroll1
(1991) pyramid’s four CSR elements that
1
(https://www.tutor2u.net/business/reference/carrolls-csr-pyramid)
Page 2 of 17
European Journal of Business &
Social Sciences
Available at https://ejbss.org/
ISSN: 2235-767X
Volume 07 Issue 05
May 2019
Available online: https://ejbss.org/ P a g e | 239
demonstrate how an organization can meet their social responsibilities. The pyramid contains (a)
Economical Responsibility- it's the first responsibility of the company which determines to benefit the
society in long term. (b) Legal Responsibility- It shows how the organization is responsible to follow all
those laws and regulations of employees such as employment, health and safety etc. (c) Ethical
Responsibility - The responsibility which dictate to act in morality or ethically i.e. taking care of
suppliers and employees. (d) Philanthropic Responsibility- This responsibility aims to give back to
society such as charitable donations etc.
CSR practices let organizations conduct their business activities in a social and ethical way to have
positive impact on society. They frame their CSR strategy by implementing different economic,
environmental and social activities. CSR is a business module which provides a balance between a firm's
financial objective and social impact in the community they conduct their operations. In recent years
researchers found that CSR has positive impact on organizational performance (Dixon Ogebechi 2011).
CSR does not only state social or environmental impact on society but definitely, the organization will
be benefited by itself for instance increasing their sales, financial performance , better image in the
society, customer’s attraction, business reputation and long term profit. In this paper, the researcher tries
to see the competitive position of Afghan private telecom companies by implementing different CSR
activities. The re-development strategy of Afghanistan right after fall of Taliban regime, many Afghan
nationals immigrated to different neighboring countries during war, upon their return to Afghanistan;
there were more open door opportunities such as job creations, new business ventures and Multinational
firms’ investment. Telecom sector of the country was re-created in 2002 by the help of multi donors’
assistance. Current USAID Afghanistan survey showed, Afghan Telecom Sector is a huge income
generating division in the country. There are many cellular companies in Afghanistan which makes a
complex competition and expectation of customer demands for reliable services. All these four private
telecom firms are (AWCC, ROSHAN, MTN and Etisalat) which provide GSM, internet and broadband
services across the country.
Statement of the Problem
Almost every business firm try to do their best in order to satisfy their customer expectations by serving
them through their goods and services, maximize their profit and keep their shareholders happy too.
There are furthermore social responsibilities of a business other than profit where a business performs
their day to day operations. In today's competitive environment any business can only survive if they
consider their core competency by applying different methods to reach out and respond every involved
parties attached to their business. They should keep a reliable working environment inside an
organization to keep their internal customers happy, providing qualitative products and services to
customers, should perform social activities in the community, maintain their environmental policy, and
keep their brand image for their competitive role among other business in the same market.
Research Question
What is the link of CSR and Competitive advantage in Afghanistan private telecom sector?
Page 3 of 17
European Journal of Business &
Social Sciences
Available at https://ejbss.org/
ISSN: 2235-767X
Volume 07 Issue 05
May 2019
Available online: https://ejbss.org/ P a g e | 240
Objectives of the study:
The main objective of the study is to evaluate the CSR activities and competitive advantages of the
cellular phone companies in Afghanistan. More specifically the objectives are i.e.
1. To identify CSR practices of Afghan private telecom companies.
2. To explore the CSR competitive advantages among selected companies.
3. To find out the significant relationship between CSR and competitive advantage of private telecom
sector in Afghanistan.
Literature Review
The Evolution of CSR from 1950s - 1990s
During last few decades’ researchers have been taken more interest in CSR to further elaborate it. The
1950s were seemed as modern era of CSR and it was known as Social Responsibility or SR that
time. The notion of CSR has been integrated in businesses for centuries. In 1950s Howard Bowen wrote
a book by the name of Social Responsibilities of the Businessman, which stated that which sort of
responsibilities should be done by businessmen that are expected by society. The CSR definition was
further explained by Davis during 1960s as “The businessmen should take discretionary effort and
should go beyond the company’s technical or economical attention”. Frederick in 1960 and Carroll in
1990 specified that businessmen should maintain all their operations, production and distribution for the
welfare of public that should meet their expectation (Carroll 1999, 271). Corporate Philanthropy and
Stakeholder theory were established in 1970s. Johnson in (1971) proposed that all stakeholders as
consumers, suppliers, employees and communities should be given value rather than only profit.
During 1980s the concept of CSR was taking more important in to consideration and elaborate few more
CSR definition as compared to 1970s. The researchers argued on business environment and emphasis
them to meet society’s benefit and their best interest as expected. Many scholars contributed and added
more in CSR, business ethics during (1990s) and the major of it was by (Carroll 1999). Wood Carroll
explained CSR law, rules and social responsibilities which are still valid in today’s community. Mr.
Wood developed four part CSR pyramid in which CSR addresses economic, legal, ethical and
philanthropic expectations by society from an organization.
Methodology
There are four private telecom companies in Afghanistan; AWCC, ROSHAN, Etisalat and MTN which
institute the population of this study. The study was exploratory in nature. this research has been
conducted from secondary sources based on available data in firm’s annual reports, websites and social
Medias while primary data was collected based on five Likert scale questionnaire distributed by google
forms survey tool which was experienced an easy, cost effective and time saving source to collect data.
The research questionnaire was developed to meet the study objectives. The focus of research was keen
